-----In 2004 we bought a falling-down house and 30 acres. This blog documents our progress-----

Saturday, February 11, 2006

great scavenging finds (pt 2)

I was sure I'd posted this already but I can't find it... so here's a belated post about yet more of my Dad's wonderful finds from back in early December.

First, some glorious windows, which will probably end up being used in the renovations of the old cottage:

colonial windows

In Dad's words:
"They require some work to bring to good shape, but are sound. One is higher than the other. Where would you envision using these? I thought the lounge/kitchen but not side by side of course. They would work well with your large front window. I had to go to Healesville for the windows, but they were not to be missed. $50 each"


Next this fabulous door:

old large door

"The big door is oversized, solid timber 1 1/2 inches thick with panels that could be removed and have glass or leadlight panels. I thought you would have some notion of where to put it. It is an external door, but could be used on the door to the alcove if a large size is wanted there. A bit of a waste. I thought it would be great as a back door, opposite the large front door. Ideas wanted here as to best use of this great door. It is in excellent condition, and will stain beautifully if that is wanted. I got it from the same person as the windows for $30".
Finally some bathroom fittings, again destined for the old cottage:

brass fittings for bathroom

"I have solid brass old tap fittings and shower head that could be used in the shower or for the bath in the loft. I would go for the loft position. Not got the back plates or handles, but these could be complementary from another source. Let me know if you like them and if you want them. I was given them from the attic extension because the plumber Diana used wouldn't fit them to the handbasin she bought secondhand".

My Dad is wonderful.

new mudroom layout (still WIP)

A few days ago we got an email from Eric, with a sketch of a new idea for the mudroom incorporating the downstairs loo:

mudroom feb62006

This works better than the previous one because the loo area feels more self-contained. But unfortunately it still doesn't feel right.

I know we'll be using this loo a lot, and that visitors will too. I don't want the toilet area itself to feel like a cubicle in a corridor, not so cramped. I also know that the mudroom will become a dumping ground for 'mess' from Dave and for all that stuff that you have to put away but just can't face doing at that moment. This means the mudroom will live up to its messy name a lot of the time... but I don't want the mess visible every time you go to the loo! The sliding door will help but it also has the effect of making it feel very enclosed, and so I know most of the time we'll end up leaving the door open.

I'm wondering whether the solution is just to bite the bullet and accept that we need a bigger space in this wing. What if we moved over the 'secret garden' verandah by the width of the passage? Or, What if we stretched out that entire side of the house, getting extra space in the lounge as well as the library wing? Perhaps then we could even keep the same floor area in the library by nudging the boundary of the mudroom wall back a bit, thus getting us even more space for the mudroom/bathroom bit? That way maybe we could get that glorious cupboard back with space for all the cleaning junk, and get back to the lovely feel that it had before we started trying to squeeze in the loo.

I feel I'm being awfully fussy but I don't want to forever kick myself when I live there for not fixing it.

Sunday, February 05, 2006

Smith Museum of Stained Glass (Chicago)

OK this is a bit off-topic, but since I posted about Oak Park I figured I may as well put the rest up too. We went to this museum in the evening. It's at Navy Pier which is a very odd place for a museum... but nonetheless it was great. The windows were installed in lightboxes in the corridor so you could just wander through at your own pace.

If you want to see them all, you can look here but here's a sampler. My favourites, of course, were all by Tiffany:

landscape with waterfall (tiffany) unknown name but by tiffany another by tiffany the life return
john the apostle writing on island of patmos (tiffany) p7 garden with fountain leaves on diamond pattern

A tour of Oak Park neighbourhood

After the tour of Frank Lloyd Wright's house & studio, I went on a walk to see some of the other houses in the neighbourhood (armed with an ipod shuffle audio guide from the shop). It's a pity the sun wasn't out, but it was still interesting, although I'd hate to live there as you'd feel on show all the time!

What struck me the most is that if you'd shown me a photo of his houses, and I'd not known their provenance, I'd have guessed they were 1960-70's era. That's the time I associate (at least in Australia) with flatter roofs, horizontal emphasis, chunky block pillars, etc. But these houses are 100 years old! That alone makes me appreciate what a visionary he was.

Here are my pictures and links to find out more information about each house (including nicer photos). You can also see the full set of my photos here.

Robert Parker house (1892)
This house is at 1019 Chicago Avenue and is one of the 'bootleg' houses, in that he designed it secretly while still working with Louis Sullivan's firm. I liked it a lot from the outside, far more so than many of his other houses, but that's because I guess I just prefer that Victorian/QueenAnne-ish style! To me, this house is combining the best of that style with the best of Frank Lloyd Wright (although I'm sure he would totally disagree). You can get more information about it here.
013 robert parker house at 1019 chicago av

Walter Gale house (1893)
This house is another of his bootlegs, at 1031 Chicago avenue. I like it for similar reasons, although it errs a bit too much on the side of 'fairy tale' for my taste. In particular, I'm not sure if I like or dislike the elongated window feature but it's interesting, I've not seen it done before. You can see more pictures of it here.
016 walter gale house at 1031 chicago ave

Nathon Moore house (1895/1923)
This house is at 333 Forest Avenue and is among the most schizophrenic of buildings I've ever seen, at least from the outside. Tudor on one side, gothicky windows in the front and then "modern" on the other. You can find out more about it here.
031 nathan moore house at 333 forest ave 027 nathan moore house at 333 forest ave
025 nathan moore house at 333 forest ave

Hills de Caro house (1896/1906)
This house is at 313 Forest Avenue. I was quite intrigued by the windows, they seem to be almost crouching over each other. You can find out more about it here.
033 hills decaro house 313 forest ave 034 hills decaro house 313 forest ave

Arthur Heurtley house (1902)
This is at 318 Forest Avenue. I really dislike the outside, but the inside I imagine is wonderful. The chimney is actually in the middle of the house... the audio guide said there was a lovely open fireplace in the centre of the main room. You can find out more about it here.
035 arthur heurtley house 318 forest ave 036  arthur heurtley house 318 forest ave

Laura Gale house (1906)
This is at 6 Elizabeth Court, which is a small road running off Forest Avenue. This was on a much smaller scale to the other houses, and to keep the cost down even further seems to be primarily concrete! I don't like it much from the outside, although I think the giant planter at 2nd storey level is interesting... it's the size of a small wading pool! Of course, totally impractical in that you'd need a giant ladder to reach it, but nice concept. You can find out more about it here.
039  laura gale house at 6 elizabeth ct

Peter Beachy house (1906)
This is at 238 Forest Avenue. If I was forced to live in one of his Prairie Style houses, this would be it. I imagine it's wonderful from the inside, but I don't like the outside much. You can find out more about it here.
041 peter beachy house at 238 Forest Ave

Frank Thomas house (1901)
This is at 210 Forest Avenue. It was the only one which had the stained glass windows I'd expected to see from Frank Lloyd Wright. You can find out more about it here.
047 frank thomas house at 210 Forest Ave

Harrison Young house (1895)
This is at 334 Kenilworth Avenue. You can find out more about it here.
080 Harrison Young house at 334 Kenilworth


The houses above are all Frank Lloyd Wright designs. But there are other old houses, mixed in, from the same era and I found it interesting to see how they compared. Here are a few of them:

8 Elizabeth court (1871)
I liked the porch entrance especially. It is right next door to the Laura Gale house and I'd guessed it was relatively newly built from a kit, until I read about it here! It was apparently originally in another site on Kenilworth and not moved to this location until 1899.
040 cute entrance at 8 elizabeth court

300 Kenilworth Ave (1890)
This is now a B&B and was pointed out on the FLW tour as being a great example of Queen Anne style. It was designed by Wesley Arnold who apparently also designed the house where Ernest Hemingway was born.
058 queen anne style house at 300 kenilworth ave

308 Kenilworth Ave (1886)
This was pointed out as being a classic example of Stick style architecture. It was apparently built from a pattern book so the architect is unknown.
060 stick style house at 308 kenilworth

John Rankin house (1889)
This is at 245 Kenilworth Avenue and was designed by Patton & Fisher. You can find out more about it here.
065 john rankin house at 245 kenilworth (not FLW)

408 Kenilworth Ave (1890/1908)
This was apparently remodelled so extensively in 1908 by Tallmadge & Watson, that all traces of the original Queen Anne house vanished!
081 408 kenilworth (not FLW)

Simpson Dunlop house (1897)
This is at 417 Kenilworth Avenue and was designed by EE Roberts. You can find out more here.
082 simpson dunlop house at 417 Kenilworth (not FLW)

Charles Matthews house (1909)
This is at 432 Kenilworth Avenue and was designed by Tallmadge and Watson. You can find out more here.
084 charles matthew house at 432 Kenilworth (not FLW)

Americus Melville house (1904)
This is at 437 Kenilworth Ave and was designed by EE Roberts. You can find out more about it here.
086 abmelville house at 437 kenilworth

Frank Lloyd Wright's Chicago home

Back in early January I was in Chicago, fleetingly, for business. Sadly I ended up working the entire time we were there, except for a free afternoon the day before we left. So, I went to visit Oak Park, Frank Lloyd Wright's old neighbourhood.

Now, I'm not a Frank Lloyd Wright fan, in the sense that I wouldn't ever like to live in his houses. A lot of his interiors are beautiful but they don't fit me... and his houses don't look very welcoming from the outside (at least to my eyes). But, he's been so influential I thought I'd see what the fuss was about.

The centrepiece of Oak Park is the Frank Lloyd Wright Home & Studio, at 951 Chicago Avenue. It was among the first houses he designed and was very different to what I expected.

This is what it looks like from the outside at the front on Forest Avenue, which was the entrance to the house:

001 front garden of frank lloyd wright family home

It was very unusual to have the bricks on show as the base, but that was done deliberately to provide a kind of visual anchor. I like the wooden shingling and how it matches the leading in the window. Apparently this was deliberate to have diamond paned leading to make it seem like the 'shell' of the house continued over the windows.

But, I don't like the front path layout. It was done deliberately so you enter from the side, walk straight up and then across, to make you take the time to observe the garden and house from different angles. It was a big difference from the more welcoming Victorian approach of having a path straight from the gate to the front door... I don't like it, it feels too guarded.

This is what it looks like from the Chicago Avenue side, which was the entrance to his studio

003 sideview of FLW studio

I like the concrete planters that are built in as part of the balastrading. It's an unusual entrance... first, there are two entrances and so apparently he used to watch potential clients entering and judge how they'd react to his ideas based on how they chose to enter!

It's unusual in that it has statues up high, effectively on the roof. According to the guide, this was a bit of arrogance, in that the octagonal studio roof was so unusual that he expected people to look up and thus they'd be in view! There's also all sorts of elaborate carving on the pillars, each with a symbolic meaning.

Overall, I found it intriguing, but I'm not sure I like it.

To see inside, you have to go on a guided tour. As it was midweek and offseason, I lucked out and there were only 5 of us, with a guide who'd been working there for over 20 years and been instrumental in its restoration. She told us some great stories.

For instance, the house had been almost derelict after spending many years converted to a rooming house... it was about to be demolished but then the Louvre museum asked to salvage some of the rooms. The city council then figured if one of the top museums in the world thought it was valuable, perhaps they should reconsider smashing it up! Thank God for the French (and I don't say that very often).

Also... when he built there it was the middle of nowhere, still dirt roads, and hardly any other houses around. Very soon after his house was finished, the lot RIGHT NEXT DOOR was bought and they built a classic Victorian style house, right up against the boundary! So he then had top remodel the entire side of that house to try and block out the view of nextdoor... that's why windows on that side tend to be high up rather than at a level you could look out of.

As per usual, they wouldn't let you take photos inside, so the pictures below are scanned from the guidebook. (This is by no means a substitute for the book though, it's well worth buying if you're ever visiting). If you want to follow along, this is the floorplan.

The first room you enter is the entrance hallway, and I was astonished.

entrance hall

It felt so very English! Oak everywhere, tasteful shades of green, even a classical frieze up high on the walls. It felt a lovely warm and welcoming place, nothing like the feeling I had outside.

You then veer left and it opens out into the main living area, complete with a stereotypical Arts & Crafts inglenook. (The entrance hall is on the far right of the first photo). It's quite a large open space, with built in seating, in a kind of L-shape leading into a small dining area.

lounge area

dining area

This whole area just felt lovely to be in.

We walked through to the dining area and then out into a kind of mini-hallway, to the left of the 2nd of the pictures above. This had the most glorious pantry area, complete with a hatch for passing food through into the dining area.

pantry outside dining area

I just adore this... you really can't beat a well-crafted built-in cabinet.

We then walked across the hall (which you could also reach directly from the front entrance area) to the more formal dining room. This was quite dark because the windows were so high up, to block the view of next door, but it had a lovely skylight positioned right over the table.

formal dining room

Except, it's not a skylight! It is wrought ironwork, with japanese paper behind it and lamps above. Apparently before dinner parties, Frank Lloyd Wright used to unscrew it and prop up some branches in there, so it gave the effect of being a skylight with the shadows of trees! It's a very clever idea.

After a brief peek into the kitchen we then went upstairs. The first room we saw was the children's bedroom, which started out as one big room and as the family grew it got divided in half... except he kept the top part open. Our guide, who'd interviewed several of his children, said that during the day the mattresses were kept in cupboards along one wall and only rolled out (japanese style) at night, with the girls on one side and boys on the other. Of course the inevitable mayhem ensued of the kids throwing things over the wall to each other etc!

Nowadays, the dividing wall is still there but it's set up as part office, part single bedroom.

kids bedroom

After that, we moved onto the master bedroom. The thing that I liked here was the attention to detail. The same chain that is in the mural painting is reflected in the shape of the hanging lights, and so on. I like the oak, but I don't like the shape of the roof... it reminds me of a barn!

master bedroom

This house was special when it was built for having the 'modcon's. In fact, when it was built it was before electricity, but as he knew it was coming he planned in for it. Heating wise, he apparently bought the steam from a factory 10 miles away and piped it in...except that a lot of the heat got lost enroute so it didn't work too well, but it was a valient attempt! But most amazing of all, it had indoor bathroom plumbing!

This is the bathroom, not bad even by today's standards:

bathroom

What I found most interesting about this was the way he positioned the window... it looks into the alcove behind the sink, so you get a sense of natural light but with absolute privacy.

The other bedroom on this floor was the South bedroom, most notable to me for having the built-in radiator cover benches. I also likedthe lowered ceiling with the small windows marking the drop.

south bedroom

But the piece de resistance, and the room that the Louvre most wanted, was the children's playroom. This has a giant barrel ceiling and windows designed deliberately to be a children's height. The mural over the fireplace was chosen to reflect one of the Ali Baba stories, which the kids nominated as their favourite.

playroom

At the opposite end of the room from the fireplace is a little stage area, where the kids could play and give concert recitals. There is a grand piano built in under this but it apparently sounds dreadfully muffled. Overall, it seems pretty formal for a playroom, but it has a nice spirit to it and I love all the oak.

playroom (other end)

From there, our tour moved from the family part of the house over to the studio extension. On our way out we passed through a hallway that appeared to have a tree growing through it! Nowadays it is just a fake effect, but apparently in the beginning it really was a tree branch. The problem was though that it killed the tree, because part of its trunk was inside the house and getting heated, it put out buds too early and was killed by the winter. I really like the idea of making your house feel part of nature by having it seem like a tree is growing through it... I'd love to do this at Amherst in the study, perhaps, but I'd make it a much bigger branch!

hallway with tree


This is the entrance hall to his studio:

studio entrance

Although I don't care much for the patterns here, what I took from this is the notion of stained glass rooflights! It gives a lovely soft lighting effect.

At one end of the studio is his office, where he used to sell ideas to clients. This is a really nice room and quite practical even given it's odd shape. By having the windows up high he used all the walls for cupboards and corkboards, to pin out plans. I can imagine it was quite an impressive environment for selling.

octagonal study

Our guide said that during it's days as a rooming house, this office was split into two with one part being a bathroom! It's hard to imagine how odd that must have felt.

At the other end of the studio area is the split level space where all his employees worked - draftsmen, craftsmen working on particular furniture pieces, whatever. Notice the chains especially... they are integral to the stability of the building, by providing the force that holds the octagonal shape together.

drafting room

The things that look like pillars on the ground floor are actually specially designed cupboards, where plans were stored. They were on casters so the room could be rearranged easily. There was also a big safe in one wall, that wasn't for valuables but instead for keeping plans to protect them from fire.

And that's the end of the tour.

Overall, I found it far more fascinating than I'd expected, and there were a couple of ideas (fake skylights, stained glass roof windows) that might even come in handy at Amherst!

Saturday, January 14, 2006

some more ideas from our architect

Yesterday we got an email from Eric commenting on our recent blog post about the floorplan. Here's what he said, with our initial reactions:

"I've gone through your blog. Everything you say sounds fine. I've had a couple of ideas for the upstairs bath and the mud room.

One issue with the bath is to make sure that room is still a nice balanced shape. I've put together a little idea which I have attached. The main bath and chair area would be 2.6 x 3.1m with the basin and shower sitting outside of that".


idea for bath

We really really like this. We measured out the size of the main bathroom area (ie: without the shower, sink) and it is pretty big, about two thirds the size of our conservatory here. It seems big enough to feel spacious but not so large that if feels cavernous. I especially like the idea of having the changing ceiling levels.


"With the mud room, I'm concerned that lots of the storage (and usefulness) would be lost. The idea that I sketched up addresses some of that. It includes the WC but keeps the bench space and even adds some shelves for shoes, bags etc. We mainly lose floor space which is mainly an issue if you have a few people in there at once".

idea for mudroom

Dave really likes this but for some reason that I can't yet pinpoint, I feel uncomfortable with it. I don't know if it's because the basin is in the open, because of the sliding door, or because there seem acres of bench space - maybe I'd feel better if some was replaced with a giant cupboard? I agree though it's an improvement on our previous idea, it's just that unlike the bathroom it doesn't yet feel right to me "gut feel". I need to sleep on it, that usually helps clarify things!


The ideas around the kitchen all sound fine. Deleting the WC can allow the kitchen pantry to increase. I'd be tempted to leave the wall where the WC door was blank for a nice piece of furniture rather than a built in bar. Perhaps the bar could be in the furniture? It would be a good place for furniture as it id directly opposite the the entry. Indeed, the kitchen is quite large. I'd love to spend some time seeing what more we could do with it -- like seats, desks etc.

I like the idea of leaving the hall wall blank... and perhaps this could be a good place for our prized sideboard? That would be well suited to double as a bar, if Dave wants (albeit he'd have to be very careful not to leave ringmarks!)

It will be great to think more about the kitchen layout specifically. I think our fears about it being so large are partly just because we can't properly envision it yet. I'd like to do the same for the entrance hall area too, at least the bit that is under the stairs.


"The balcony upstairs would definitely be fun. It might create some difficulties with the roof. It's worth looking into, though, and see what it would look like.

If you are anything like us, you'll use you outdoor BBQ a lot. At this time of year, we cook outside about five nights a week. By winter, we're all dying for baked food, but it's amazing what you can do on a BBQ. It's fine to delete the sink from the screened area and concentrate on the verandah.

The next step for me is really to draw it up more accurately (probably on CAD) and also do some larger scale detailed sketches of the areas like the bath, mud room, kitchen etc. Once I've done all that, I'll build a model to see what it really looks like. (It might sound odd putting it on CAD before the study model, but computer drawings are so easy to change, I like to start using them in the design stage.)"


Yippee, models! I'm looking forward to one day being able to "fly through" a mockup of the house like you see on those TV shows.